A Dress Question

I recently ordered this shirtdress from ModCloth:

Broadcast Coordinator Shirtdress

thinking it would be a perfect work dress for this coming fall and winter. It's professional without being stuffy, has some texture with the clip dotted material, provides the kind of coverage I prefer, AND pockets! Alas, when it arrive the bust was WAY too tight, I could get it buttoned, but it was bordering on absence. Yes, I could have gone up a size, but maybe it's my vanity, or the fact that from my perspective my body is still in transition from having my baby... but I just didn't want to go up. So I returned it.  Looking back over my past ModCloth orders I've returned more things than I've kept over the past two years... and I'm starting to realize I've aged-out of ModCloth. 

But all is not lost, I've started digging into eShakti and I think my work dress conundrum will soon have a solution, but I need your help! Which dress? 

A.

Cotton Knit Retro Shirtdress

This knit number is right up my alley with it's silhouette and rich jewel tone, plus it looks really easy to wear and a great dress to pair with boots and blazers. 

B.

Constellation Print Crepe Shirtdress

Five years ago, heck two years ago, I would have been all over this celestial print, BUT even with all the eclipse mania I don't think this particular novelty pattern suits me. However I REALLY dig this silhouette, waistline, sleeves, and collar of this frock. Sign me up for this exact dress in a different print. 

 C.

Polka Dot Cotton Knit Dress

Speaking of prints, hello polka-dots my old friend! The only thing I'd change here is the neckline. I'm more a V-neck lady, which IS an option with eShakti, you can customize necklines, sleeves, & lengths!

 D.

Bird Print Georgette Dress

Love the retro feel of this dress! But I'm not so sure about the waist embellishments...

E.

Floral Dot Print Georgette Maxi Shirtdress

I would opt for a midi hem on this frock. The neckline, sleeves, and print are all working for me, or are they? Those poppies seem a bit too bright, no? 

F.

Floral Dot Print Crepe Shift Dress

Like the maxi above, this shift also sports a layered floral and dot print. I like that the sash belt is removable since  I'd style this with a leather or stretch belt to better cinch the waist. 

G.

Star Print Crepe Pleated Maxi Dress

Another maxi that I'd customized with a shorter hem. And, while I wasn't too crazy about the constellation pattern in dress B. above, I think a star pattern is more doable, it's closer to a polka dot than a novelty print. 

H.

Floral Bird Print Georgette Shirtdress

Florals with birds in this choice, with another removable fabric belt, but this time rendered as a shirtdress. 

I'm sure you can see the theme here, dark background dresses with standard prints in midi lengths and sleeves, and of course pockets* They are very similar and I need some opinions on this one. Which dress? A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H!!! So many good options! Leave your choice in the comments! 

I also couldn't help but put this whimsical piece on my wishlist.....

Night Sky Print Georgette Jumpsuit 

Yep, a starry-print jumpsuit. I know I was all uppty about the celestial print of the second dress and now I'm thinking of spending dough on a very impractical jumpsuit.  But, it IS super cute, right? 

Thanks for voting! 

*I've decide I will no longer shop for dresses without pockets, they are essential for a busy woman like myself. And, if pants don't have proper pockets you can for get about it!